TRANSPARENCY, BEFORE TRUST

How WeLiveCrypto works

Every score, badge and warning on WeLiveCrypto follows the rules on this page. Read them to understand what a listing tells you, and what it does not.

01

The three scores

Every listed project has three scores from 0 to 10:

  • Reputation: how trustworthy the project looks from its record — age, guarantee funds, audits, community standing, member feedback and its listing status.
  • Privacy: how well the project protects its users — for example KYC requirements, Tor access and Monero support.
  • WLC score: the average of the two.
WLC score = (Reputation + Privacy) ÷ 2

Scores are relative within an industry

Each project collects reputation points and privacy points. Its total is then compared with the best Approved or Verified project in the same industry, which gets 10.

Score = project points ÷ best project’s points in the industry × 10

Example: if the best exchange has 400 reputation points, an exchange with 300 points gets 7.50 and one with 100 points gets 2.50. When a stronger project joins, the others move down.

Score colours

≤ 0 Red
0–4 Orange
4–6 Amber
6–8 Yellow-green
8–10 Green

A 10 is a comparison with other projects, not a safety guarantee. Always check the details and the feedback before you send funds.

02

How points are earned

Each industry has its own list of parameters. Staff decide how many reputation and privacy points each answer is worth, so a feature that matters for mixers can count differently for exchanges.

Facts we calculate ourselves

  • Age: from the business launch date, so the score rises as the project gets older.
  • Tor access: from the recorded .onion addresses.
  • Monero (XMR): from the list of supported coins.
  • Liquidity band: from the recorded liquidity amount, only when the project has its own liquidity.
  • Guarantee fund: from the escrow amounts, valued in US dollars when staff checked them, so price swings do not move the score.

Facts entered by staff or the project

  • KYC level: the level the project declares counts. Documents only support it.
  • External audit: counts only when a link to the audit is recorded.
  • Customer support rating: a staff assessment of the project’s support service.
  • Where several answers can be ticked, some parameters count only the best one. For example, a mixer with several mixing methods scores for its strongest method only.

Unknown is not “No”

When we do not know an answer, it gives no points and is shown as unknown. It never counts as a negative finding.

03

Listing statuses

Pending
Submitted and waiting for a staff review. Not shown in the directory.
Approved
The available information had a first, reasonable check. Not every detail has been verified, so Approved is not a guarantee that a project is safe.
Verified
Our highest status (the blue badge), given by staff after a careful review. The project’s information is checked to be as close to 100% accurate as possible, and the project has either a guarantee fund (escrow) worth at least $20,000, or at least three years of verifiable business history and reputation. Staff decide whether a project qualifies. Only Verified projects can advertise on WeLiveCrypto.
SCAM
Staff found evidence of a scam. See Scam warnings below.
CLOSED
The project is no longer in business. See Closed projects below.

The status also counts towards Reputation: a Verified project earns three times the status points of an Approved one.

04

Community reputation

Many projects have announcement threads, forum profiles or social channels. Staff assess each recorded link and mark its standing as Good, Mixed, Bad or Scam accusations.

  • Platforms count differently: Bitcointalk counts most, then Altcoinstalks, Reddit and other sites.
  • Good and Mixed standing count more the longer the project has been active there.
  • Bad standing and scam accusations always count in full, and are never hidden by a good record elsewhere.
  • The project’s best positive link counts in full; other good links add only a small, capped bonus.

Assessed links show their standing on the project page. Links that have not been assessed give no points.

05

Member feedback

Forum members can leave positive, neutral or negative feedback about a project they used. Staff review every piece of feedback before it appears.

  • Members can attach proof, such as a transaction or a signed message, for staff to check.
  • Signed messages (PGP or Bitcoin) are checked automatically.
  • Members and the project can reply. Replies are reviewed too, and replies from the verified owner are marked.
  • The number of approved positive, neutral and negative reviews counts towards Reputation, in steps: up to 2, up to 5, up to 10, up to 20, and more than 20.
06

Ownership verification

The green Ownership verified badge means we confirmed who runs the project. It is separate from the blue Verified status, and a project can have both.

  • The owner starts a claim and proves control of the official website, either with a WeLiveCrypto badge carrying a personal code or with the code on a page of the official domain.
  • Staff review the claim before it is approved.
  • We check the owner’s badge again every day. If it is missing for more than 7 days, the owner is alerted. Ownership is never removed automatically.
  • Verified owners are expected to take part in disputes about their project.
07

Flags

Any community member can report a problem with a listing. Staff review each report, and only confirmed problems become flags. Project pages show them under “Reported issues”, with a short public summary. Private evidence and discussions are not shown.

Each open flag: −2 Reputation · at most −6 (three flags) · never below 0
  • The deduction is taken from the final 0–10 Reputation score, so it also lowers the WLC score.
  • When the problem is fixed, staff mark the flag resolved and the points come back. Resolved flags stay listed on the project page.
  • A dispute that ends Unresolved or against the project adds a flag automatically.
08

Disputes

When a member has a problem with a project that they cannot solve directly — for example a delayed withdrawal — they can file a public dispute. WeLiveCrypto staff mediate between the member and the project.

  1. Filing A registered forum member describes the problem, with evidence. Each image can be marked private, so only the parties and staff see it.
  2. Review Staff check the dispute before it becomes public. Disputes without a real case are rejected.
  3. Mediation One mediator takes the dispute. If the project has no verified owner, the owner is invited to claim the listing first.
  4. Replies Each side has a time limit to reply, shown as a countdown: usually 7 days for the owner to claim the listing, 7 days for the project and 14 days for the member. The mediator can extend it.
  5. Outcome The mediator closes the dispute with a public note.
Resolved
The problem was solved. Any flag added by the dispute is removed.
Unresolved
The project did not solve the problem or did not reply in time. A flag is added to the project.
Decided against project
The mediator found the project at fault. A flag is added, and staff may also mark the project Scam.
Closed – no reply
The member stopped replying. No effect on the project.

Staff can reopen a closed dispute. Posts are never edited or deleted; abusive posts can be hidden by staff. Browse disputes →

09

SCAM Scam warnings

Staff mark a project Scam only with a written record: the kind of scam (for example exit scam, phishing or fake proofs), a public explanation, the date and at least one evidence link.

  • Reputation and WLC score are set to −10, whatever the other points are. A high privacy score cannot hide a Scam warning.
  • The project page shows the warning and its evidence at the top, with no Visit button and no advertising. Known addresses are listed as plain text, never as links.
  • The earlier listing information stays available below the warning, and members can still leave feedback.
10

CLOSED Closed projects

When a project stops operating, staff mark it Closed with the reason (for example closed by the owner, inactive, website gone or acquired) and, where there is one, a link to the service that continues it.

The page keeps the score the project had when it closed, together with its history and past feedback, so its record stays readable.

11

Updates and corrections

  • Scores are recalculated automatically a few minutes after any change.
  • Project websites are checked regularly, and the page shows whether they are reachable. This does not change the score.
  • Status changes and information updates appear in the project’s history and in the public Change Log.
  • If something in a listing is wrong, use “Suggest a correction” on the project page or contact staff. Project owners can claim their listing to keep it up to date.

Explore the directory →